The Game Changer’s Dilemma: Consumer Response to Inclusive Product Design in the Video Game Industry
Abstract:
Research on Corporate Sociopolitical Activism has largely focused on public statements as the primary channel through which firms take stances on sociopolitical issues. However, firms have also embedded sociopolitical commitments, particularly to Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion, directly into their products, making “inclusive product design” perceived by consumers a salient yet understudied form of CSA. Drawing on research on signaling, reactance, and authenticity, we theorize that directly experiencing inclusive features through product consumption may activate mechanisms that operate alongside ideological alignment: authenticity concerns, perceived imposition, and perceived quality trade-offs. Using data on 10,193 video games reviewed on Metacritic between 2014 and 2022, a period marked by the growing politicization of DEI in public discourse, we find evidence of an aggregate negative response to inclusive product design. This response is amplified when games include post-access monetization, which makes commercial motives conspicuous, but mitigated when games afford players greater autonomy or receive credible external quality endorsements that alleviate quality concerns. A preregistered experiment corroborates our findings, particularly among politically conservative consumers, and shows that perceived quality trade-offs operate differently across ideological groups. We contribute to CSA research by extending it into the product domain and advancing understanding of consumption-specific mechanisms that shape responses.
Contact Emails:
qjoanne@ceibs.edu